Septic owner guide
What gets fixed on an old septic tank that stays in the ground
On most older systems around Pocatello and Chubbuck, the concrete box in the yard is still sound long after the parts that go with it have failed. A lid cracks or a baffle drops into the sludge. Those get fixed from the open lid with the tank pumped empty, and the tank stays where it is.
When something goes wrong with a septic system, the tank gets blamed first, since it is the part everyone knows is there. On an older place it is rarely the part that failed. What follows walks an old tank the way it looks on a pump-out day, from the lid down to the walls.
What gets repaired on a septic tank when the tank itself is fine?
Usually the parts, not the box. Septic tank repair in Pocatello on an older system means the lid and riser at grade, the seams where they meet the tank top, the inlet where the house line comes in, the baffles or tees at each end, and the effluent filter housing if the tank has one. The concrete tank is usually still sound after every one of them has failed.
A concrete tank is a thick, heavy box sitting in settled ground, and as long as nothing crushes it or floats it, very little wears it out. The parts have it harder. The lid sits up in the freeze-thaw zone, the seams under it shift a little each time the ground does, and the baffles stand in sewage and sewer gas for decades. On a 1970s house out past Tyhee or up on the benches, the first question after a problem is which part gave out, and that gets answered with the lid off and the tank pumped down. Some of these repairs can wait for the next pump-out. A couple should not.
What does a broken baffle look like with the lid off, and what goes in its place?
With the tank pumped down, a broken concrete baffle shows as a jagged stub on the tank wall in front of the pipe, with the missing piece lying on the floor in the sludge. An old steel baffle shows rust eaten through where it was welded on, sometimes hanging by a corner. The usual replacement is a plastic sanitary tee fitted to the end of the inlet or outlet pipe.
None of that is visible on a normal day. At its working level the tank has a scum mat across the top and sludge over the floor, so a baffle that fell off years ago looks the same from the opening as a sound one. It gets seen during septic tank pumping, once the hose has the tank down near the floor.
Older concrete tanks around Pocatello mostly have baffles cast into the tank or set as a slab in front of each pipe. Sewer gas eats at concrete above the waterline, and the joint where the baffle meets the wall weakens until the piece cracks and drops. Steel tanks on pre-1980 acreage builds had steel baffles welded in, and those fail at the weld first.
A sanitary tee is a T-shaped fitting on the end of the pipe inside the tank, its lower leg reaching below the scum layer and its top left open to vent. The broken piece of the old baffle comes out with the pumping where it can. On the outlet end, an effluent filter housing can often go in place of a plain tee, where the opening and the outlet height leave room for one. Its removable screen catches fine solids a tee lets through and gets rinsed at each pump-out from then on.
A broken inlet baffle can usually be put right on this visit or the next. A missing outlet baffle belongs on this visit, since until it is fixed the scum and floating solids leave with the water, out toward the drain field. On a steel tank, a baffle rusted off at the weld is a reason to look hard at the rest of the steel.
Can a cracked concrete lid be replaced without digging the tank up?
Yes. A lid is a separate piece resting on the tank’s opening, and a cracked one is lifted off and replaced on the tank that is already there. The only digging is what it takes to uncover the lid, and that dig is the natural moment to bring the access up to grade with a riser.
Old concrete lids crack here the way old sidewalks do. Water works into the concrete and freezes, and enough Pocatello winters turn a hairline into a crack and then a broken corner. A lid under a foot or two of soil gets less of it than one flush with the lawn.
A cracked lid over an open tank is a fall hazard, so nobody steps on it or runs a mower over it until it is replaced. It also lets water in, which is the next question.
With the old lid off and the opening exposed, the new one can go back at the same depth or come up to the surface on a riser. A riser installed at grade runs $250 - $450, with the depth to the lid setting where in that range it lands (see what a riser costs alongside the rest of the price table).
A hairline crack in a lid buried under sod can wait for the next pump-out, when the lid is coming off anyway. A lid at grade with a broken corner or a sag in the middle should not.
How does groundwater get into a septic tank, and how is a leaking seam closed?
Through the joints. Water gets in at the seam between the lid or riser and the tank top, at a riser joint that has settled and opened, or around a pipe where it passes through the tank wall. The tell is a tank that reads full of clear water soon after a pump-out. The fix is resealing or resetting whichever seam is leaking.
On the Portneuf river-bottom lots, the spring water table can rise to the tank top or above it. An old joint keeps sewage in well enough, but once the water outside stands higher than the water inside, groundwater pushes in. It pushes hardest right after a pump-out, when the tank is close to empty. A tank pumped in early spring that is back up to its outlet within a day or two, and full of clear water rather than the usual gray, is filling faster than the house could fill it. Sometimes it shows on the day, a trickle running down the wall from a joint while the hose works. That is water getting into the tank, a different problem from a drain field sitting in high groundwater.
Up on the benches along Johnny Creek, Gibson Jack and Buckskin the ground drains fast, so the same open seam takes snowmelt instead. A riser in a low spot of the yard collects the melt off the lawn in March and sends it down the joint.
Closing a leaking seam is work done from the top. The old joint between riser and tank is cleaned out and resealed, or a riser that has settled off-level is lifted, set back on a fresh seal and leveled. Where a pipe passes through the wall, the gap around it is sealed at the wall. On a river-bottom lot, a seam that leaks every spring is worth closing before the next spring, since the groundwater that gets into the tank goes on to the field with everything else.
What can go wrong where the house line enters the tank?
Two things, both fixed at the tank. The seal where the inlet pipe passes through the wall can crack or pull loose, and the inlet baffle or tee in front of it can break or plug.
A settled inlet pipe often shows at the wall as a gap, or a pipe end sitting lower than the hole it came through, which lets soil and water in around it. It gets reset and resealed where it meets the tank. Roots, sags and blockages farther up the pipe toward the house are a different job, covered in the guide to telling a blocked house line from a full tank or a drowned field.
What makes a septic tank too far gone to fix?
A tank is past fixing when the box can no longer hold water in, keep groundwater out, or carry the weight above it. On an older system that is less common than a failed part, and it shows in a few specific ways once the tank is pumped down.
- An old steel tank rusted through at the waterline or across the top. Steel does not patch in any lasting way, and a top that has rusted thin can give way under someone walking over it.
- A crack through a wall or the floor that lets groundwater in or effluent out. Fine surface crazing on old concrete is common and often harmless. A crack that weeps water while the tank is pumped down is a different matter.
- A top slab that is crumbling around the opening or has sagged in the middle. A lid can be replaced, but the slab it rests on cannot.
- A tank that has tilted, shifted or floated, or cracked under a vehicle or a load of fill driven across it. A tank pumped empty while the water table stands high around it can lift out of level, a real risk on the river-bottom lots in spring.
How long each kind of tank usually lasts is laid out in the guide on how long a septic system lasts.
Replacing a tank is excavation and a new install, and that is work we do not do. When the look after a pump-out turns up one of the conditions above, we say so, and tell you what kind of outfit puts in a new tank. A broken baffle, a cracked lid or a leaking seam on a sound tank is septic tank repair, and the tank stays in the ground. Either way, what you should hear once the tank has been pumped and looked at is which part failed, whether the tank around it is sound, and whether the fix belongs on this visit or can wait for the next one.